lastID = -10108700
Skip to main content Skip to top navigation Skip to site search
Top of page
  • My citations options
    Web Back (from Web)
    Chicago Back (from Chicago)
    MLA Back (from MLA)
Close action menu

You need to login to use this feature.

Please wait a moment…
Please wait while we update your results...
Please wait a moment...
Description: Access Water
Context Menu
Description: Full-scale demonstration of micro-aeration for hydrogen sulfide control at the...
Full-scale demonstration of micro-aeration for hydrogen sulfide control at the Chambers Creek Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant
  • Browse
  • Compilations
    • Compilations list
  • Subscriptions
Tools

Related contents

Loading related content

Workflow

No linked records yet

X
  • Current: 2024-06-17 15:49:47 Adam Phillips Release
  • 2024-06-17 15:12:00 Adam Phillips
  • 2024-06-17 14:46:03 Adam Phillips
  • 2024-06-17 13:15:18 Adam Phillips
  • 2024-06-17 11:16:26 Adam Phillips
Description: Access Water
  • Browse
  • Compilations
  • Subscriptions
Log in
0
Accessibility Options

Base text size -

This is a sample piece of body text
Larger
Smaller
  • Shopping basket (0)
  • Accessibility options
  • Return to previous
Description: Full-scale demonstration of micro-aeration for hydrogen sulfide control at the...
Full-scale demonstration of micro-aeration for hydrogen sulfide control at the Chambers Creek Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant

Full-scale demonstration of micro-aeration for hydrogen sulfide control at the Chambers Creek Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant

Full-scale demonstration of micro-aeration for hydrogen sulfide control at the Chambers Creek Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant

  • New
  • View
  • Details
  • Reader
  • Default
  • Share
  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • New
  • View
  • Default view
  • Reader view
  • Data view
  • Details

This page cannot be printed from here

Please use the dedicated print option from the 'view' drop down menu located in the blue ribbon in the top, right section of the publication.

screenshot of print menu option

Description: Full-scale demonstration of micro-aeration for hydrogen sulfide control at the...
Full-scale demonstration of micro-aeration for hydrogen sulfide control at the Chambers Creek Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant
Abstract
Wastewater utilities are increasingly engaged in projects that beneficially utilize biogas in renewable energy applications. Although the degree to which the biogas must be cleaned or upgraded will depend on its end use, the removal of hydrogen sulfide (H2S) to varying degrees will always be required. Historically, hydrogen sulfide has been treated using chemical scrubbers or adsorptive processes, but these tend to be costly and maintenance intensive. The addition of small amounts of oxygen, whether by air or high purity oxygen systems, to anaerobic digesters has been reported to be an effective and economical mitigation measure for hydrogen sulfide. The Pierce County Department of Public Works and Utilities (County) uses digester gas at their Chambers Creek Wastewater Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant to power boilers which were installed in 2016. Although the boilers are relatively new, the County has had to replace fouled boiler tubes approximately every six months of operation due to the levels of hydrogen sulfide in the biogas (2200 ppm, on average). (Figure 1) Consequently, the County requested that Brown and Caldwell (BC) evaluate different technologies to reduce hydrogen sulfide concentrations to levels closer to boiler manufacturer recommendations (10 parts per million by volume [ppmv]), which would in turn reduce maintenance and costly tube replacement. Although the use of sacrificial media is a feasible alternative and one that the County may implement in coming years, the level of treatment required for the current biogas hydrogen sulfide concentrations would require frequent and costly media replacement. BC recommended that the County pilot microaeration, which would not reduce H2S concentrations to the levels required but rather extend the life of any adsorptive/sacrificial media and reduce associated operating costs. The pilot design was informed by a literature review conducted prior to implementation in order to ascertain appropriate design and control parameters and to review the particular importance of biogas residence time in gaseous hydrogen sulfide removal efficiency and air requirements for effective sulfide reduction. Residence times of approximately five hours showed a relatively consistent removal of 90%; the results of the literature review on air quantity required was mixed. Various sources indicated that, in pilot systems, approximately two to three times the theoretical air requirement was needed to affect the anticipated hydrogen sulfide reduction, while in full scale systems, about four times the theoretical air requirements are needed, potentially due to mixing and oxygen transfer as well as different surface area-to-volume ratios. A linear relationship between mass of air supplied and mass of H2S removed was reported to be approximately 2.05 kg O2/kg H2S removed, which is again four times the theoretical value based on oxidation to sulfur. Finally, oxygen concentrations in the digesters subjected to microaeration were found to be on the order of 1-2% The Chambers Creek microaeration pilot was designed in two phases. Data on two digesters receiving the same feed loads (total and volatile solids) were collected as part of phase one, prior to the beginning of aeration, in order to baseline existing conditions and variations in digester operation (see Table 1). Data were collected for approximately five months between August and December of 2021. Phase two began in January of 2022; one digester was chose as the treatment digester, and one as the control. 90 scfh of plant air was introduced into the sludge feed line upstream of the treated digester through an air injection assembly, with data continuing to be collected on both digesters for comparison. The initial aeration dose was chosen based on the County's desire to maintain the minimum reported oxygen level of 0.2% in the digester so as to minimize disruption to the digestion process. At biogas sulfide loads of approximately 16kg/day, the air flow rate of 90scfh corresponds to a ratio of 1.03 kg O2/kg H2S and a molar ratio of 1.09 mol O2/mol H2S. At these ratios, approximately 12% removal in hydrogen sulfide (mass basis) in the aerated digester was realized after three weeks of operation. Both the mass and molar ratios are generally lower than those identified in the literature review, data that, when coupled with the significantly lower biogas residence time, indicate that lower aeration rates may still positively impact sulfide removal. The full-scale demonstration of micro-aeration at Pierce County, resulted in an approximate 15% reduction in the biogas hydrogen sulfide levels; a reduction less that that reported possible in the literature. An evaluation of the data, digester microbial population data and digester gas system inspection provided valuable lessons learned surrounding the implementation of microaeration at scale. These include: - The addition of small quantities of oxygen do not negatively impact the anaerobic community. - Surface area is critical for microaeration to successfully remove H2S - Digester gas management systems in systems with microaeration should be designed such that biofilm and sulfur management are possible (Figure 2) - Microbial community analysis indicates that primary H2S metabolism is likely to be in the biofilm and not the bulk digestion phase. - Online monitoring is critical to process success and control, with feedback control (Figure 3) - Digestion processes that have relatively small headspaces (ex. egg-shaped digesters, submerged fixed covers) may want to consider ex-situ treatment of H2S. This paper will discuss the results of this pilot as well as the lessons learned and how they may be applied to future installations to mitigate the challenges of this emerging process.
This paper was presented at the WEF Residuals and Biosolids Conference, June 18-21, 2024.
SpeakerMuller, Christopher
Presentation time
10:45:00
11:15:00
Session time
08:30:00
11:15:00
SessionEnergy Management: From Production to Safety
Session number25
Session locationOklahoma City Convention Center, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma
TopicBiogas Cleaning, Biogas desulfurization, Microaeration
TopicBiogas Cleaning, Biogas desulfurization, Microaeration
Author(s)
Muller, Christopher
Author(s)C. Muller1, K. Guevarra2, A. Summers2, P. Zemke1, K. Woodland1, V. Hollingsworth1, E. Bronstad1
Author affiliation(s)Brown and Caldwell 1; Pierce County Public Works and Utilities 2; Pierce County Public Works and Utilities 2; Brown and Caldwell 1; Brown and Caldwell 1; Brown and Caldwell 1; Brown and Caldwell 1;
SourceProceedings of the Water Environment Federation
Document typeConference Paper
PublisherWater Environment Federation
Print publication date Jun 2024
DOI10.2175/193864718825159476
Volume / Issue
Content sourceResiduals and Biosolids Conference
Copyright2024
Word count17

Purchase price $11.50

Get access
Log in Purchase content Purchase subscription
You may already have access to this content if you have previously purchased this content or have a subscription.
Need to create an account?

You can purchase access to this content but you might want to consider a subscription for a wide variety of items at a substantial discount!

Purchase access to 'Full-scale demonstration of micro-aeration for hydrogen sulfide control at the Chambers Creek Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant'

Add to cart
Purchase a subscription to gain access to 18,000+ Proceeding Papers, 25+ Fact Sheets, 20+ Technical Reports, 50+ magazine articles and select Technical Publications' chapters.
Loading items
There are no items to display at the moment.
Something went wrong trying to load these items.
Description: Full-scale demonstration of micro-aeration for hydrogen sulfide control at the...
Full-scale demonstration of micro-aeration for hydrogen sulfide control at the Chambers Creek Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant
Pricing
Non-member price: $11.50
Member price:
-10108700
Get access
-10108700
Log in Purchase content Purchase subscription
You may already have access to this content if you have previously purchased this content or have a subscription.
Need to create an account?

You can purchase access to this content but you might want to consider a subscription for a wide variety of items at a substantial discount!

Purchase access to 'Full-scale demonstration of micro-aeration for hydrogen sulfide control at the Chambers Creek Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant'

Add to cart
Purchase a subscription to gain access to 18,000+ Proceeding Papers, 25+ Fact Sheets, 20+ Technical Reports, 50+ magazine articles and select Technical Publications' chapters.

Details

Description: Full-scale demonstration of micro-aeration for hydrogen sulfide control at the...
Full-scale demonstration of micro-aeration for hydrogen sulfide control at the Chambers Creek Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant
Abstract
Wastewater utilities are increasingly engaged in projects that beneficially utilize biogas in renewable energy applications. Although the degree to which the biogas must be cleaned or upgraded will depend on its end use, the removal of hydrogen sulfide (H2S) to varying degrees will always be required. Historically, hydrogen sulfide has been treated using chemical scrubbers or adsorptive processes, but these tend to be costly and maintenance intensive. The addition of small amounts of oxygen, whether by air or high purity oxygen systems, to anaerobic digesters has been reported to be an effective and economical mitigation measure for hydrogen sulfide. The Pierce County Department of Public Works and Utilities (County) uses digester gas at their Chambers Creek Wastewater Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant to power boilers which were installed in 2016. Although the boilers are relatively new, the County has had to replace fouled boiler tubes approximately every six months of operation due to the levels of hydrogen sulfide in the biogas (2200 ppm, on average). (Figure 1) Consequently, the County requested that Brown and Caldwell (BC) evaluate different technologies to reduce hydrogen sulfide concentrations to levels closer to boiler manufacturer recommendations (10 parts per million by volume [ppmv]), which would in turn reduce maintenance and costly tube replacement. Although the use of sacrificial media is a feasible alternative and one that the County may implement in coming years, the level of treatment required for the current biogas hydrogen sulfide concentrations would require frequent and costly media replacement. BC recommended that the County pilot microaeration, which would not reduce H2S concentrations to the levels required but rather extend the life of any adsorptive/sacrificial media and reduce associated operating costs. The pilot design was informed by a literature review conducted prior to implementation in order to ascertain appropriate design and control parameters and to review the particular importance of biogas residence time in gaseous hydrogen sulfide removal efficiency and air requirements for effective sulfide reduction. Residence times of approximately five hours showed a relatively consistent removal of 90%; the results of the literature review on air quantity required was mixed. Various sources indicated that, in pilot systems, approximately two to three times the theoretical air requirement was needed to affect the anticipated hydrogen sulfide reduction, while in full scale systems, about four times the theoretical air requirements are needed, potentially due to mixing and oxygen transfer as well as different surface area-to-volume ratios. A linear relationship between mass of air supplied and mass of H2S removed was reported to be approximately 2.05 kg O2/kg H2S removed, which is again four times the theoretical value based on oxidation to sulfur. Finally, oxygen concentrations in the digesters subjected to microaeration were found to be on the order of 1-2% The Chambers Creek microaeration pilot was designed in two phases. Data on two digesters receiving the same feed loads (total and volatile solids) were collected as part of phase one, prior to the beginning of aeration, in order to baseline existing conditions and variations in digester operation (see Table 1). Data were collected for approximately five months between August and December of 2021. Phase two began in January of 2022; one digester was chose as the treatment digester, and one as the control. 90 scfh of plant air was introduced into the sludge feed line upstream of the treated digester through an air injection assembly, with data continuing to be collected on both digesters for comparison. The initial aeration dose was chosen based on the County's desire to maintain the minimum reported oxygen level of 0.2% in the digester so as to minimize disruption to the digestion process. At biogas sulfide loads of approximately 16kg/day, the air flow rate of 90scfh corresponds to a ratio of 1.03 kg O2/kg H2S and a molar ratio of 1.09 mol O2/mol H2S. At these ratios, approximately 12% removal in hydrogen sulfide (mass basis) in the aerated digester was realized after three weeks of operation. Both the mass and molar ratios are generally lower than those identified in the literature review, data that, when coupled with the significantly lower biogas residence time, indicate that lower aeration rates may still positively impact sulfide removal. The full-scale demonstration of micro-aeration at Pierce County, resulted in an approximate 15% reduction in the biogas hydrogen sulfide levels; a reduction less that that reported possible in the literature. An evaluation of the data, digester microbial population data and digester gas system inspection provided valuable lessons learned surrounding the implementation of microaeration at scale. These include: - The addition of small quantities of oxygen do not negatively impact the anaerobic community. - Surface area is critical for microaeration to successfully remove H2S - Digester gas management systems in systems with microaeration should be designed such that biofilm and sulfur management are possible (Figure 2) - Microbial community analysis indicates that primary H2S metabolism is likely to be in the biofilm and not the bulk digestion phase. - Online monitoring is critical to process success and control, with feedback control (Figure 3) - Digestion processes that have relatively small headspaces (ex. egg-shaped digesters, submerged fixed covers) may want to consider ex-situ treatment of H2S. This paper will discuss the results of this pilot as well as the lessons learned and how they may be applied to future installations to mitigate the challenges of this emerging process.
This paper was presented at the WEF Residuals and Biosolids Conference, June 18-21, 2024.
SpeakerMuller, Christopher
Presentation time
10:45:00
11:15:00
Session time
08:30:00
11:15:00
SessionEnergy Management: From Production to Safety
Session number25
Session locationOklahoma City Convention Center, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma
TopicBiogas Cleaning, Biogas desulfurization, Microaeration
TopicBiogas Cleaning, Biogas desulfurization, Microaeration
Author(s)
Muller, Christopher
Author(s)C. Muller1, K. Guevarra2, A. Summers2, P. Zemke1, K. Woodland1, V. Hollingsworth1, E. Bronstad1
Author affiliation(s)Brown and Caldwell 1; Pierce County Public Works and Utilities 2; Pierce County Public Works and Utilities 2; Brown and Caldwell 1; Brown and Caldwell 1; Brown and Caldwell 1; Brown and Caldwell 1;
SourceProceedings of the Water Environment Federation
Document typeConference Paper
PublisherWater Environment Federation
Print publication date Jun 2024
DOI10.2175/193864718825159476
Volume / Issue
Content sourceResiduals and Biosolids Conference
Copyright2024
Word count17

Actions, changes & tasks

Outstanding Actions

Add action for paragraph

Current Changes

Add signficant change

Current Tasks

Add risk task

Connect with us

Follow us on Facebook
Follow us on Twitter
Connect to us on LinkedIn
Subscribe on YouTube
Powered by Librios Ltd
Powered by Librios Ltd
Authors
Terms of Use
Policies
Help
Accessibility
Contact us
Copyright © 2024 by the Water Environment Federation
Loading items
There are no items to display at the moment.
Something went wrong trying to load these items.
Description: WWTF Digital Boot 180x150
WWTF Digital (180x150)
Created on Jul 02
Websitehttps:/­/­www.wef.org/­wwtf?utm_medium=WWTF&utm_source=AccessWater&utm_campaign=WWTF
180x150
Muller, Christopher. Full-scale demonstration of micro-aeration for hydrogen sulfide control at the Chambers Creek Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant. Water Environment Federation, 2024. Web. 15 Jun. 2025. <https://www.accesswater.org?id=-10108700CITANCHOR>.
Muller, Christopher. Full-scale demonstration of micro-aeration for hydrogen sulfide control at the Chambers Creek Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant. Water Environment Federation, 2024. Accessed June 15, 2025. https://www.accesswater.org/?id=-10108700CITANCHOR.
Muller, Christopher
Full-scale demonstration of micro-aeration for hydrogen sulfide control at the Chambers Creek Regional Wastewater Treatment Plant
Access Water
Water Environment Federation
June 21, 2024
June 15, 2025
https://www.accesswater.org/?id=-10108700CITANCHOR